Independent replication · same harness as SUMMIT · point-in-time

ROTATOR

A biweekly leadership-rotation strategy: hold the 3 strongest-and-steadiest S&P 500 names, rotate as ranks change, and go fully to cash when SPY breaks its 210-day average. This page is our independent rebuild, run through the exact same point-in-time engine, costs and 244-window grid as SUMMIT — so the two are directly comparable. ↗ compare with SUMMIT
loading signal…
currently holding
—
30.0×
money multiple since 2006
28%
IRR · QQQ ~19% · SPY ~14%
+21.3%
median excess vs QQQ
65%
windows beat QQQ-DCA (244)
−57.5%
worst window vs QQQ
−23.4%
10th-pct window vs QQQ
Read this first. ROTATOR posts a higher terminal multiple than SUMMIT (30× vs 20×) and a high median — but it is a much higher-variance bet. Across independent rolling holding periods it beats QQQ only ~50-65% of the time, its worst window is −57% vs QQQ (SUMMIT: −10.6%), and most of its lifetime edge comes from one regime — the 2023-2026 memory/AI run (+206% vs QQQ), the very theme it holds today (STX/WDC/INTC). It also turns over ~26 trades/yr (short-term-gain tax drag) and is cost-sensitive. Higher ceiling, far higher floor risk.

Growth of a DCA

ROTATOR QQQ DCA SPY DCA Contributed

Same cadence, same 10 bps/side cost, execution at next open. × multiple = value ÷ dollars contributed. $ value = absolute dollars at $1,000 per buy, log scale. Note how nearly all of ROTATOR's separation from QQQ opens up in the final stretch (2023+).

Returns by horizon

If you had started this DCA N years ago and run it to today. Caveat: every "to-present" horizon includes the 2023-2026 boom, which flatters all of these — see the rolling-window table below for the unbiased view.

startedROTATOR ×ROTATOR IRRQQQ ×QQQ IRRSPY ×SPY IRRROTATOR vs QQQ

Calendar-year value growth

Within-year growth of the running portfolio (net of that year's new contributions), vs the same DCA into QQQ and SPY. This is where ROTATOR's variance shows: huge up years, but also flat/down years the cash switch and concentration produce.

yearROTATORQQQ DCASPY DCA

Win rate by holding length — the honest, unbiased view

Across all rolling start dates (244 windows), how often each holding length actually beat QQQ-DCA. SUMMIT shown for contrast.

holding lengthwindowsROTATOR beat QQQROTATOR worstSUMMIT beat QQQSUMMIT worst
3 years7051%−45.3%84%−10.6%
5 years6250%−55.6%92%−7.4%
10 years4252%−57.5%100%+8.4%
to present70100%+40.3%100%+45.9%

ROTATOR's "to-present" row is 100% only because every such window rides 2023-2026. On independent 3/5/10-year holds it is roughly a coin-flip vs QQQ with deep worst cases — the price of three-name concentration plus a cash switch that whipsaws.

Regime windows

regimemultipleROTATOR vs QQQSUMMIT vs QQQ
GFC 2007–20091.32×+13%+9%
Recovery 2009–20121.08×−20%+7%
Bull 2013–20172.23×+40%+27%
Sideways 2015–20161.25×+14%+4%
Vol shock 2018–190.95×−13%+1%
COVID 2020–20211.33×−4%+14%
Bear 2022–mid-20231.19×−0%+18%
AI bull 2023–20264.94×+206%+48%

ROTATOR's cash switch whipsaws in choppy recoveries (2009-12, 2018, COVID rebound) — it sells into the bottom and re-enters higher. SUMMIT stays positive in every regime by switching what it buys rather than going to cash.

SUMMIT vs ROTATOR — head to head

Both run on the identical engine, S&P 500 point-in-time universe, next-open fills, and 244-window grid. ROTATOR at its native k=3 / 10 bps; SUMMIT at k=2 / 5 bps.

metricSUMMITROTATORedge
Beat QQQ (244 windows)93%65%SUMMIT
Beat SPY98%77%SUMMIT
Median excess vs QQQ+28.8%+21.3%SUMMIT
10th-pct window vs QQQ+3.0%−23.4%SUMMIT
Worst window vs QQQ−10.6%−57.5%SUMMIT
Full-period multiple (2006→)20.0×30.0×ROTATOR
Best regime (AI bull)+48%+206%ROTATOR
Trades / year~0 (never sells)~26SUMMIT
Cost drag 5→10 bps (full mult)none32.8×→30.0×SUMMIT
Tax profiledeferred / LTmostly short-termSUMMIT

In one line: ROTATOR has the higher ceiling, SUMMIT the higher floor. ROTATOR wins terminal wealth and explosive regimes; SUMMIT wins consistency, drawdown, turnover and taxes. For buy-and-hold money you can't perfectly time the entry of, SUMMIT's 93%/−10.6% profile is the safer expectation; ROTATOR is a higher-variance satellite whose recent dominance leans heavily on one concentrated theme.

The rules (as replicated)

1 · Leadership score

Rank by average(3-month, 6-month return) × fraction of rising weeks over 6 months. "Strong AND steady beats strong alone."

2 · MAX screen

Exclude any name whose biggest 1-day jump in the past month is in the universe's top 5% — "names that just went vertical tend to give it back."

3 · Hold & rotate

Hold the top 3, equal weight. Keep a position while it stays in the top 8; sell once it drops below rank 8. Buy at next open.

4 · Cash switch

If SPY closes below its 210-day average, sell everything to cash; re-enter at the first rebalance after SPY reclaims it.

Validation

Caveats. Our replication is faithful to the published v2.0 spec but rendered in the DCA harness (regime checked at each biweekly date, not intraday) on the S&P 500 PIT universe (the original adds the Nasdaq-100). Free price data lacks ~26% of historical constituents (mostly pre-2015 delistings); the mega-/large-cap leadership tilt sits in the best-covered names, but residual survivorship bias can't be fully excluded. ROTATOR will draw down 35-50% and can trail for years when leadership is broad. Concentration is real (today: one storage/memory theme). ~26 short-term-gain sales/yr — hold in a tax-advantaged account. Past performance ≠ future results. Not investment advice.